Agreement Reached in Sandburg Coach's Sexual Abuse Case, Sentence to Come

Steven Reynolds, of unincorporated Hinsdale, will return to court for a pre-sentencing report in August.

The substitute teacher from unincorporated Hinsdale,  stemming from a Jan. 28 incident involving a 17-year-old female student, will likely be sentenced next month after it was announced Monday his attorney has reached a plea agreement with prosecutors.

Steven E. Reynolds, 27, of the 600 block of 55th Street, was serving as a sub and freshman basketball coach at Sandburg in Orland Park, when he was arrested by the DuPage County Sheriff's Office on Feb. 6 and charged with two felony counts of criminal sexual abuse.

Details of Reynolds' plea agreement were not read during Monday's brief status hearing at the DuPage County Judicial Center in Wheaton. After a conference with both sides, Judge George Bakalis said he accepted the agreement but will not proceed with officially sentencing Reynolds until after a pre-sentencing report that will take place during an Aug. 20 hearing.

DuPage County State's Attorney's Office spokesman Paul Darrah said in the case of Reynolds, a sentence from Bakalis is likely to be handed down during the same hearing, following the pre-sentencing report.

The pre-sentencing report will be attained from the probation department by Reynolds' attorneys and presented to the judge, according to Darrah. The report provides a "history or makeup" of the defendant, he said, including any background information that might provide context for the defendant's offenses.

"It is meant to help the court better understand what might have put him in this position," Darrah said.

The counts against Reynolds are Class 2 felonies, which can carry a sentence of three to seven years in prison, Darrah said in February.

Reynolds was present at Monday's hearing. He is out on bond and not in custody of the state. 

Sign up for Orland Park Patch breaking news alerts

Follow us on Facebook and on Twitter. 

Reynolds' attorney, Joseph Laraia of Laraia and Laraia, PC, has told Patch that he will not discuss the case outside of the court record.

According to the state's attorney's office, Reynolds' arrest came after the victim told her friends about the alleged sexual contact. The friends then informed Carl Sandburg school officials, who immediately passed along the information to the Orland Park Police Department. 

An investigation by the DuPage County Children's Center resulted in February's charges.

The agreement announced Monday comes after Reynolds in March. , where it was requested that the discovery stage of the case be continued.

Looking for more police news?

K July 09, 2012 at 05:42 PM
I feel bad for this guy. while I don't agree with him having a relationship with a 17 year old student....I don't agree with him being charged for it. The age of consent is 17. She went to HIS house. So let's play speculation....he wouldn't leave his wife for her boo hoo and she got mad and told her friends who told on him...boo hoo. She needs counceling. If she thinks it's ok to go to your teacher's and have relations with him. Then to turn around and talk about it and get him in trouble for her being "loose". It's disgusting to say the very least.
voklst July 10, 2012 at 12:04 AM
I do not know the parameters of the case but from my POV in my 17 yr old eyes this guy is not hot unless its his inteligent quotient (doesnt seem so at this point) on the other side...In my 53 yr old eyes this guy is not hot. Plus my husband is bald and he is Hot. So what is the appeal for the 17 yr old to even go to his house? The power to get aguy to leave his wife?
Stones July 10, 2012 at 03:28 PM
K, are you out of your mind? He's the teacher and coach, she's the student, that's a very big line to cross. Age of consent has no bearing when a relationship is based on a position of authority. Let alone the ethical points of being a teacher. If she shows up at his door, it is his ethical and moral duty to turn her away.And just how do you think she found her way to his house? In DuPage County, from Orland Park? He likely invited her or brought her there. If you are correct in pointing out her need for counseling, then he also preyed on an at risk victim, which is typical of these sick predators. See Jerry Sandusky. Hopefully you never have children, especially not daughters.
Sara Waters July 10, 2012 at 05:17 PM
K - this guy is a pig. He took advantage of her. He knew what to do to get what he wanted out of her. This guy is the one who needs counseling. This has nothing to do with him leaving his wife for her either. This has to do with a sexual predator (him) and his prey (her). You are acting like a 17 year old girl is suppose to have the life knowledge to know better. I hope that you do not have children (daughters especially) to put this kind of blame on them. I would THINK a 27 year old man would know better.
Sara Waters July 10, 2012 at 05:22 PM
No where in here does it stat the girl wanted him to leave his wife. Why are people going to this conclusion? It doesn't state he's married either. This isn't about how 'hot' he is or isn't. This guy most likely watched her and knew what to say to her. He's a predator.
Nikki G July 11, 2012 at 04:38 PM
Are you saying a 17 year old can be manipulated and somehow FORCED to go to this guy's house? I'm not saying the guy isn't a creep...he's 27 years old. But a 17 year old knows damn well what they're doing. Especially girls...and if she didn't, then her parents better make sure she doesn't go away to college...
Moonglow July 13, 2012 at 11:49 AM
Regardless of WHO went WHERE, 17 yrs old is still considered a child....... a minor who CANNOT give consent. This guy knew what he was doing........ people like him always do! He will spend in prison where he belongs! Prisoners don't take kindly to child molestors! It's likely he'll get some of his own medicine!
Nikki G July 13, 2012 at 12:32 PM
Read the law. In Illinois, 17 is legal age for consent. And in today's society, kids are growing up so fast, they know EXACTLY what they're doing.
Stones July 13, 2012 at 01:46 PM
Nikki G, age of consent doesn't matter when it involves a teacher and student relationship. And while the age of consent in Illinois is 17, there is a caveat to that rule. ■Illinois - The age of consent in Illinois is 17. It is illegal to have sex with someone under the age of 18 if you are more than 5 years older than the minor. I guess you need to read a little further into the law. If you're a minor, I hope you're boyfriend isn't more than 5 years older than you. If he is, hopefully your father will be bright enough to fix that. I find it hard to believe that any woman or girl for that matter would defend this creep.
Nikki G July 13, 2012 at 01:53 PM
I'm not defending him -- I've said that in previous comments. I'm also not a minor. Yes, the teacher should have known better...but I don't think its fair for girls to play innocent when they make poor choices.
Moonglow July 13, 2012 at 02:19 PM
Thank you Stones for your comment. And Nikki....... who said life was FAIR? Yes teen girls know how to play the "game" and to them it's just that. They don't think about the ramifications of their actions.
Billy Joe July 14, 2012 at 07:16 PM
He doesn't look creepy at all to me- in fact I think he looks dapper in that orange jumpsuit. My wife and I were married when she was 17.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something